Man who planned to eat 10-year-old girl after raping and killing her dies by Lethal injection

A death row inmate in Oklahoma received a lethal injection on Thursday, December 21, in the nation’s 25th and final execution this year.

Kevin Ray Underwood was sentenced to die for the killing of 10-year-old Jamie Rose Bolin in 2006 as part of a cannibalistic fantasy. 

Underwood, a former grocery store worker, turned 45 on the day he was executed at the Oklahoma State Penitentiary in McAlester.

He was pronounced de@d at 10:14 a.m., state Department of Corrections spokesperson Lance West told the Associated Press. Underwood’s death marked Oklahoma’s fourth execution in 2024.

The state tied Missouri with the third-highest number of death sentences carried out since January 1, following Texas, which executed five people, and Alabama, which executed six.

As Underwood’s execution began at 10:04 a.m, he looked over to members of his legal team and his family, including his mother. His breathing hitched slightly and his eyes closed a few minutes later.

A doctor entered the execution chamber at 10:09 a.m., shook him a few times and declared him unconscious. He was pronounced dead five minutes later.

Strapped to a gurney inside the death chamber, Underwood apologized to Bolin’s family and to his own family “for all the terrible things I did.”

“The decision to execute me on my birthday and six days before Christmas was a needlessly cruel thing to do to my family,” Underwood said, “but I’m very sorry for what I did and I wish I could take it back.”

Underwood admitted to luring Jamie into his apartment and beating her over the head with a cutting board before suffocating and sexually assaulting her. He told investigators that he nearly beheaded the girl in his bathtub before abandoning his plans to eat her.

Bolin’s sister, Lori Pate, who was among several relatives who witnessed the execution, thanked prosecutors for helping guide her family through the nearly 18-year process from the child’s death to Underwood’s execution.

“This doesn’t bring our Jamie back but it does allow the space in our hearts to focus on her and allow the healing process to begin,” Pate said.

During a hearing last week before the state’s Pardon and Parole Board, Underwood told the girl’s family he was sorry.

“I would like to apologize to the victim’s family, to my own family, and to everyone in that room today that had to hear the horrible details of what I did,” Underwood said to the board via a video feed from the Oklahoma State Penitentiary.

The three board members in attendance at last week’s meeting all voted against recommending clemency.

Underwood’s attorneys had argued that he deserved to be spared from death because of his long history of abuse and serious mental health issues that included autism, obsessive-compulsive disorder, bipolar and panic disorders, post-traumatic stress disorder, schizotypal personality disorder and various deviant sexual paraphilias.

His mother, Connie Underwood, tearfully asked the board to grant her son mercy.

“I can’t imagine the heartache the family of that precious girl is living with every single day,” Connie Underwood said. “I wish we understood his pain before it led to this tragedy.”

But several members of Bolin’s family asked the board to reject Underwood’s clemency bid. The girl’s father, Curtis Bolin, was scheduled to testify to the board but became choked up as he held his head in his hand.

“I’m sorry, I can’t,” he said.

Prosecutors wrote in opposing Underwood’s clemency request that, “Whatever deviance of the mind led Underwood to abduct, beat, suffocate, sexually abuse and nearly decapitate Jamie cannot be laid at the feet of depression, anxiety or (autism).

“Underwood is dangerous because he is smart, organized, and driven by deviant sexual desires rooted in the harm and abuse of others.”

In a last-minute request seeking a stay of execution from the U.S.

Supreme Court, Underwood’s attorneys argued that he deserved a hearing before the full five-member parole board and that the panel violated state law and Underwood’s rights by rescheduling its hearing at the last minute after two members of the board resigned.